Bike Fan Club By Flycor, LLC

High-end Custom Bicycles >> Calfee Design Fan Club

skagwayroadie
contributor


Reged: 12/20/03
Posts: 141
Loc: Alaska
subjectivity on wheel weights vs performance
      01/15/05 09:18 PM (64.186.108.47)

Hey guys...
After reading the posts since this thread came out it is appearant to me that what one person feels is not the same as another. This very thing came out plenty times when the subject of CF seatposts have come out. Some claim they can feel the difference a CF post over an aluminum or other post, when other say they could not. Who is right? Yes, wheel one may be lighter than wheel two, and wheel one may be more aero than wheel two, but these two things do not guarantee that wheel one is faster or better than wheel two, especially in all riding conditions. How would you rate a wheel if one measured faster than another, but the losing wheel "felt" faster, despite being measurably slower?

I think we would all agree that a lighter wheel is better than a heavier one. Whether a boutique wheel is better than a custom built one is comparing apples to oranges. If you would compare a custom set of wheels between two wheelbuilders, all things being equal, your decision would boil down to who has a better reputation, who has more experience and which costs less. How do you compare a set of custom wheels to a set of boutique wheels that are most likely machine made using that critieria? It is simply not a very fair comparison to make.

Bottom line, to me, is that if you can afford a boutique wheelset these days, you have a lot of great choices available, however it will not guarantee a won race or a superlative group ride over using a custom wheelset. It is the engine, ultimately, that gets you there first, not just a fancy set of wheels. That being said I would not argue against the psychological advantage that belief can play into this equation. That is a debate for another thread.

Okay, I am done venting, now it's time to ride...later!
...Mark

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* custom wheels...off topic waynebiker 12/27/04 01:34 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic Bruce   12/29/04 05:32 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic elvecchio   01/12/05 03:08 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic Allan   01/13/05 03:21 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic vaxn8r   01/14/05 12:40 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic Allan   01/14/05 04:02 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic vaxn8r   01/14/05 05:04 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic Dave_Thompson   01/14/05 05:14 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic Allan   01/14/05 07:43 AM
. * Proton Question Lon   01/14/05 03:00 AM
. * Re: Proton Question vaxn8r   01/15/05 05:04 AM
. * Re: Proton Question Lon   01/16/05 08:50 PM
. * Re: Proton Question vaxn8r   01/17/05 12:55 AM
. * offset spoke design rims bfd   01/18/05 06:05 PM
. * Re: offset spoke design rims Allan   01/18/05 07:44 PM
. * subjectivity on wheel weights vs performance skagwayroadie   01/15/05 09:18 PM
. * Re: subjectivity on wheel weights vs performance Allan   01/18/05 12:43 AM
. * Off topic vaxn8r   01/17/05 05:15 AM
. * Re: Off topic skagwayroadie   01/18/05 03:14 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic vaxn8r   01/13/05 03:13 AM
. * .I agree Dave_Thompson   01/12/05 04:16 PM
. * Re: .I agree Lon   01/12/05 06:53 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic dah   01/01/05 02:37 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic bfd   01/03/05 08:13 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic vaxn8r   01/04/05 04:44 AM
. * replacement rims bfd   01/05/05 06:14 PM
. * Re: replacement rims Lon   01/05/05 11:22 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic flythebike   01/04/05 02:57 PM
. * Why do people buils wheels? Mike   12/29/04 07:20 AM
. * Re: Why do people buils wheels? vaxn8r   12/29/04 07:42 AM
. * Re: Why do people build wheels? Mike   12/29/04 05:40 PM
. * Re: Why do people build wheels? vaxn8r   12/30/04 04:18 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic OnYerLeft   12/27/04 09:54 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic flythebike   12/28/04 02:49 PM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic mkg   12/27/04 04:40 AM
. * Re: custom wheels...off topic flythebike   12/27/04 02:40 PM

Extra information
6 registered and 52 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Kahuna 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 11508

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us Bikefanclub.com

*
UBB.threads™ 6.4